Hi Craig
I think your analogy is quite clever. I have a 3 year old car, I know it has an engine because I have seen it. The car just goes.
I think older cars always made one aware of their working parts, I used to have a 1275cc mini and that certainly made you think about its all its working bits.
I have 6 watches that I wear regularly, no, just one at a time.
The quartz are always time correct and ready to go. The auto with date needs the date corrected when I want to wear it, and of course the wind up needs the time set.
I don't look on the quartz as inferior which I suppose some folks do, I just appreciate their accuracy and the fact that they are no fuss watches.
I really like my autos and the wind up used to belong to my dad. Winding, setting and wearing it, always reminds me of him so it is always a pleasure.
For me the issue is more analogue or digital. I don't think I want a digital watch.
Nigel