Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have just disassembled an ETA 2789 (at least that's what's marked under the balance. It doesn't have the day display) and found the square of the winding stem to be twisted. The function of the watch doesn't seem to be impaired. Winding and setting work fine. My question is, how can this happen? It's a seemingly perfect twist (no bend), and too much torque on the crown would surely cause breakage somewhere else before the square twists. So was it made that way? Why? I've never seen or heard of anything like it.

DSC02042.thumb.JPG.775750ad6d7ae23b83adf7bbaf477a8a.JPG

Posted

Indeed this is one of those movements that uses a twisted stem... No worries.

Usually I've found these on ladies calibers... Never on men's but who knows...

  • Like 1
Posted
5 minutes ago, Chopin said:

Usually I've found these on ladies calibers... Never on men's but who knows...

ETA 2824-1 is like that. I think the idea is that the twist helps the setting lever in keeping the castle wheel pressed.

  • Like 1
Posted

My wife's Squale Diver had a twisted stem and when I cleaned and repaired it I thought I had to bend it back. Lucky I stopped to think.

Sent from my GT-N5110 using Tapatalk

  • 1 year later...
Posted

I have a watch with a twisted stem.  Like others, I thought it was a problem.  After researching, I discovered that it was ok.  Searched the forum to find this thread which is helpful, but still scratching my head as to how a twisted stem makes things work better. 

In the worst-case scenario, could it be replaced with a straight stem?  Just curious...not an issue for me now.

Posted
55 minutes ago, LittleWatchShop said:

but still scratching my head as to how a twisted stem makes things work better. 

The twist drives the winding and sliding pinions towards each other which enhances the grip for their clutch action. 

  • Like 1
Posted
1 minute ago, Nucejoe said:

The twist drives the winding and sliding pinions towards each other which enhances the grip for their clutch action. 

Ahhhh...I see it now.  Blinding glimpse of the obvious!  Thanks!!

Posted
Just now, LittleWatchShop said:

Ahhhh...I see it now.  Blinding glimpse of the obvious!  Thanks!!

I didn't say it quite right in previous post. Actually only the sliding pinion gets driven towards the winding pinion.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • By the way, I opened my watch, looked under a magnifying glass, there is simply no grease, the screws are without traces, the slots are intact.I think it's just a matter of maintenance.there are no rotor marks on the body. And to remove the strap from yours, just press on the 1st side,and slightly move the strap, then on the other side and it will come off.
    • Hi My name is Chris. Just started trying to learn about watch and clock repair as a result of repairing my fathers old 1890s police station clock (about a year ago). The clock was Ok, but having graduated to pocket watches and then wrist watches, despite the really excellent stuff on Youtube, I am struggling a bit.  As a retired engineer, I find the engineering exquisite, but a bit on the fiddly side.  I have done a few practice watches with a little success but failed a few, but have had success with Seiko 7005s, 7009s etc, but have just attempted a citizen 5430.  Nightmare.  My wife thought I had found religion as I spent so much time on my knees with my eyes to the floor looking for springs.  Got through that and found that the balance is shot.  Trying to source one or something that will fit from the citizen range has me totally perplexed.  Tried Ebay, Cousins etc without luck.  Any advice as to alternatives that will fit or alternative sources would be gratefully received.
    • Agreed, this is puzzling. Can you ask questions or inspect the lots before bidding? My Boley & Leinen Reform face plate is dia. 95mm exactly. It's possible that 4 inches is a slightly too large approximation, but why then make the distinction to 3 11/16 for the sake of 8mm? If the larger ones are truly 4" then they will clash with the bed, but then I have no idea which 8mm lathe would take them. All 8mm lathes have spindle height 50mm or less, as far as I know. The spindle height is, as you say, standard 50mm for W.W.
    • I have only been a member for six years & I have found this a very friendly forum although I don’t have anything to do with watches not because I don’t like watches but because I have gout in both hands so my dexterity isn’t very good, I restore torsion clocks & occasionally other antique clocks also at 72 my eyes are not what they used to be, that is why I only post on the clock forum & the lathe forum mostly . As others have said Mark it is much appreciated that  you are willing & able to do this. very many Thanks Dell
    • Ah, this is brilliant, thank you very much!
×
×
  • Create New...