Jump to content

Recommended Posts

On 2/20/2014 at 6:34 AM, Ashnz said:

Hello to all,

My name is Ash (from NZ). Im a watch enthusiast and trying to learn more about Horology.

I have been picking odd watch repair jobs here and there and self-learning.

Firstly, thanks a lot to Mark Lovick for uploading fantastic videos on youtube that are so simple to follow. Keep up the great work :)

Question - is there a way to diagnose quartz watch circuit using those test probes (that have an LED inbuilt) or perhaps using a multi-meter? For some watch movements such as Myota 2035, it makes sense to replace the whole movement. In other cases, it make sense to repair it (if possible).

Is there a way to narrow down the faults in quartz watch? For instance, if a watch is gaining/loosing time, it could be the quartz crystal out of freq etc. how can it be scanned appropriately?

Im not sure if its even possible or not. Hopefully I could get some help here.khz. 

Thanks a lot in advance

Ash

Hi Ash, you would need an Accurate frequency counter.  Look across the XTAL or from the XTAL OUT to the Batt+ve rail for 32768 Hz. (32.768 KHz) There is a Small Cap from XTAL out to the batt +v rail,  preset at the manufacturer for final trimming. You can slow the Osc down by making a gimmick Cap of say 6 twisted ECW turns tight together,  Solder it from XTAL ouput to +v rail or across the XTAL and then trim to length for the correct frequency. Good luck with this one .  Always set for a slight gain say 0.2 Secs/day. Early Quartz watches did have adjustment but not nowadays. You can only speed the Osc up by filing the actual XTAL element or changing the Osc trimming cap for one with less capacitance. I was an electronic engineer and I could not be bothered with this.  Always try cleaning the watch first or give it the line free treatment. I hope this is of help, Mike.

Edited by ecodec
More info.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 years later...

I watched this very good video today.

As an electrical engineer, I can see that a tool to make all of those measurements would be very straightforward to make--I could readily design the circuit.  However, the mechanical aspects (e.g., the pogo pins) would take some effort to copy (not hard, just effort) and then a nice case, etc.  The Witschi machine is a nice ergonomic user interface in a compact footprint.  Seems quite cool (under my breath...I want one).

Then I wonder...for a professional, what is the ROI for a $2500 machine that is for testing/repairing quartz watches?  How many customers do you have with a quartz watch needing repair?  Many quartz watches are made of cheap no-jewel movements that are just a few dollars to replace.  I have recently opened/seen a number of quality ETA quartz movements...but still...these movements (if replaced) do not appear to be very expensive.

OK, so if you have a shop where people come in for a battery change.  Maybe that is when you take the watch, run all of the tests, replace the battery and charge...dunno...$25.  Almost no material cost, some time cost, and the rest writes down the Witschi.  I could work through this business case analysis but will wait to hear from the professionals.

Looking forward to hearing from the professionals on this topic!

BTW, I want that Witschi Handy II.  I have more money than good sense, so who knows...we shall see.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, LittleWatchShop said:

Then I wonder...for a professional, what is the ROI for a $2500 machine that is for testing/repairing quartz watches?  How many customers do you have with a quartz watch needing repair? 

You have to think that these machines, as well other expensive ones, plus the need of filtered air, refrigerated lubricants storage, and other stuff possibly, are made mandatory by the big Swiss brands for watchmakers that want to be accredited as a service center. Expensive yes, but when you can start applying their service prices, even a an Euro 50,000 investment is justifiable. That is less than some cafe-bistro renovations.  Beside, capital cost goes (amortized) on the balance sheet for tax purposes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, jdm said:

Beside, capital cost goes (amortized) on the balance sheet for tax purposes.

In the US, I can write off a capital cost in one tax year, so if I spent the 2.5k, the fed would subsidize roughly 30%, so my out of pocket is more like 1.75k. 

I suspect that the only quartz repairs that people would pay for would be for high-end watches.  I have no feel for what that market is like.  Most people I know either wear an apple watch or no watch at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, LittleWatchShop said:

I suspect that the only quartz repairs that people would pay for would be for high-end watches.  I have no feel for what that market is like.  Most people I know either wear an apple watch or no watch at all.

Beside that a 5K or even a 20K watch is far from being high end, what I was trying to say is that having the full tools list that counts. The presence of a quartz tester is just a detail, but is needed for becoming official. I even know of a reputable independent watchmaker that has the Analyzer, his waiting list is very long and his prices are high. He can take both mechanical and quartz watches (most others are snob and won't touch quartz) for service or repair, and having the full arsenal at his disposition to do the best job. Also, machines attract and impress customers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you really were a professional would this not be something better to have?

https://www.witschi.com/en/group-of-devices/measurement-of-electronic-watches/analyzer-q1/analyzer-q1.html

it does so much more and it has a nice color screen it even does mechanical watches it looks really impressive on your bench. so how do I know it looks impressive on your bench well it's sitting on my bench at work. The real question is how much use does it get? It doesn't work for tuning fork watches so I have to have my separate power supply and meter for that. Usually if I measuring coil resistance I grab my $20 DVM. Behind me as a really nifty witschi timing machine for mechanical watches with a microphone that rotates around so why should I even use this for mechanical watches although it does have the standard witschi microphone for mechanical watches.

if it's never being used why is it even on my bench? This is because the owner of the shop at one time had a much nicer shops spread out so this meant multiple of watchmakers could have timing machines. The real reason exist is he was attempting to get Swiss part 6 pounds which required fancy equipment. Like the $16,000 cleaning machine which does a really impressive job I'm not sure he could justify the 16,000 but since we haven't.

I think realistically the only way you could justify these machines if you were servicing high-end quartz watches then you should probably have one. But what's interesting today as people by what I perceived to be expensive wristwatches and inside is a five dollar quartz movement. Which means we do a heck of a lot of movement replacements. The only time we actually service a  quartz watch is if it's something that cannot be replaced as a replacement is no longer available. But seeing as how I'm the only one of services the quartz watches I can't actually remember when the last one I actually serviced was I'm sure I did one this year maybe? Fortunately if you're a company trying to please the Swiss impressing them with all your expensive tools to get their parts then you don't have to justify the existence of these machines.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can't imagine what the Witschi can do better than bog standard electronics kit other than having everything in place in one simple package. If you compare it to the cost of a decent Tektronix scope and Fluke multimeter when new there's not much difference. However, I bet the Witschi holds its value for an age after the scope and multimeter have been dismissed of as old tech. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, Plato said:

Tektronix scope

I always remember the sticker shock of a brand-new timing machine that spit out paper versus the cost of a really nice Tektronix oscilloscope. On the other hand how many people even back then were buying timing machines brand-new versus the electronics world buying oscilloscopes?

1 hour ago, LittleWatchShop said:

How much is that Q1?  Julesborel has it but "call for price."

I'll have to remember to ask what they paid for it. I only remember the really expensive stuff like the cleaning machine to this always really impressive to say that cost $16,000. on the other hand does do a really nice job of cleaning and makes all kinds of nice interesting sounds when it's a vacuum pulling all those fluids into its chamber.

then if you want to compare prices what about this this is a bargain compared to the witschi?

https://www.esslinger.com/horotec-flash-tester-quartz-watch-tester/

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, JohnR725 said:

then if you want to compare prices what about this this is a bargain compared to the witschi?

If money were no object then I'd buy a suite of Witschi equipment.

However, the closest I can afford is what I picked up on ebay a few years ago. A Portescap 5007. It has three probes so one for +V, one for gnd and the other to take measurements. I just had to make some leads for my PSU and scope. Under £30 including the connectors:

IMG_0004.thumb.JPG.b8b40bb89a5d53248b02fa68997846f1.JPGIMG_0005.thumb.JPG.665f5047b5f915ce9a41264073a05549.JPGIMG_0006.thumb.JPG.7ebebc27d5a00f0300c9a07f92d79433.JPGIMG_0007.thumb.JPG.ff3444585df34c17209bc84aec3b3212.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lots of good input from you guys.

It seems to me that when working on a quartz watch the main thing I would want to do is measure currents in the various modes and measure coil resistance.  That would tell me if there were an issue with the train and/or stepper.  If the indication is the train wheels, then a cleaning may be in order.  If the coil resistance is off, then it can be replaced.  Other than those, you are not going to replace the crystal. If the watch is dead you can replace the entire electronics, or replace the movement.

Measuring the accuracy seems to have no value--what do I do if it is off?  There is no adjustment, right?  The adjustment is stored in OTP/EE and can only be changed if EE and what tool do I need for that?  It would be movement specific.

So, at the end of the day, I think I just need to measure currents.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hooked up a multimeter between the power supply and power to the module to measure current.

I have replaced a couple of crystal oscillators to get a quartz running, the only problem is that sometimes a modern crystal isn't the same shape as an old one as seen in the photos. Mine is the top one (original crystal), the other I got off the internet.

There is an adjustment, I think it's a variable capacitor to tune the oscillator circuit - also shown in the photos. Not sure if they bother with more modern watches?

IMG_0002.thumb.JPG.8cdf526c1a567fc0d6bf19a4c7465f97.JPGwp93138960_05_1a.jpg.cdd7e340ae8fd51ab63d881c91c2d6a7.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

30 minutes ago, Plato said:

There is an adjustment, I think it's a variable capacitor to tune the oscillator circuit - also shown in the photos. Not sure if they bother with more modern watches?

These are vintage quartz watches. The date code on the first one is 1972.  For sure, I can see replacing crystals on these because they can be tuned ("pulled" as we say) with the variable capacitor.  The modern quartz watches (at least some of them) have programmable memory on board the IC which is used to make the adjustments.  There are no adjustments on these.  If you replace the crystal on one of them, It will not be as accurate as it was before...but it will at least work.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, LittleWatchShop said:

So, at the end of the day, I think I just need to measure currents.

probably the most important is the ability to measure the current but? It's also nice to have a variable voltage power supply. One of the tests when servicing quartz watches is the see how low in voltage you can go and still have the watch run.

1 hour ago, Plato said:

There is an adjustment, I think it's a variable capacitor to tune the oscillator circuit - also shown in the photos. Not sure if they bother with more modern watches?

usually all the early quartz watches had a trimmer capacitor for regulation purposes.  modern watches the quartz crystal usually oscillates fast and they use some sort of digital regulation system. Program at the factory either one time or with a eeprom. Either way it doesn't really matter to us the timing machines that used to be able to program these only existed over a narrow window of time and I don't think they ever release the programming algorithms. On the other hand if you do have a timing machine that can pick up the quartz crystal oscillation it's nice to know that it's actually oscillating at somewhere near the correct frequency.

 

witschi Knowledge Quartz Watch.pdf

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

We actually learned (in the late 90s) to switch out quartz canisters and so forth. I remember thinking "no one will ever pay enough for this to happen" at that time. I finally did solder in a variable capacitor a few years ago on a watch, for a watchmaker friend who doesn't know how to solder, on a watch that was worth it.

 

Witschi stuff is true industrial grade pro stuff. I don't have any quartz testing equipment, but my SS1 for mechanicals has conservatively around 20,000 cycles on the automatic mic and it looks and works like new 14 years later. 7500 bucks and worth every penny. For quartz testing of coils and current consumption I think anyone light versed in electronics can get around Witschi with a decent Fluke.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, LittleWatchShop said:

These are vintage quartz watches. The date code on the first one is 1972.  For sure, I can see replacing crystals on these because they can be tuned ("pulled" as we say) with the variable capacitor.  The modern quartz watches (at least some of them) have programmable memory on board the IC which is used to make the adjustments.  There are no adjustments on these.  If you replace the crystal on one of them, It will not be as accurate as it was before...but it will at least work.

'72 from the Motorola chip? Yes it's a Girard-Perregaux from that era. 

Getting it to work is better than nothing, it's next to impossible to find a circuit for some old models. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you're looking for a little history on quartz watches or electric watches there's a book found at the link below.

website is interesting in that if you click on the tab of contents you get a list of the contents of the book. Click on each of the ease and you get the text from the book. Then at the bottom of the page there is a link to the photograph associated with the pictures found in the book.

https://doensen.home.xs4all.nl/index.html

https://www.amazon.com/Watch-Modern-Wristwatch-Design-1950-1983/dp/905349135X/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=Pieter+Doensen&qid=1631047366&sr=8-1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Plato said:

I've got a copy of Doensen's book, I purchased it direct from his website so I got it signed by him too 

nice that he signed your book. out of curiosity looking at mine I don't see a signature. On the other hand mine got personalized in another way?

15 minutes ago, Plato said:

There's another good book covering the same topic:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Electrifying-Wristwatch-Lucien-F-Trueb/dp/0764343041

I've seen your book recommendation before I don't have a copy. Strangely enough I probably wasn't paying attention or just wasn't thinking about it this time one of the authors jumped out which is Gunther Ramm. If you look at Peter's book you'll find that he's the first person that he thanks for helping with his book. Then there's a whole bunch of other people for which my name is in there also. The world of electrical horology tends to be relatively small as typical watch collectors view things that have wires batteries or integrated circuits as the work of the devil.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, JohnR725 said:

On the other hand mine got personalized in another way?

Interesting...

6 minutes ago, JohnR725 said:

for which my name is in there also.

more interesting...

 

7 minutes ago, JohnR725 said:

The world of electrical horology tends to be relatively small as typical watch collectors view things that have wires batteries or integrated circuits as the work of the devil.

Give it time (pun intended!) I've noticed that the most common profession on here and the BHI is Electrical/Electronics Engineering so it might be an outdated generalisation?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Similar Content

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I often think about painting clear varnish on the coil.
    • I hate this battery release design in Ronda movements. It's an accident waiting to happen. One slip and the coil is gone. I wonder if it's a deliberate design.
    • so let's break this down the words restaffed balance wheel correctly would mean no distortion at all on the balance wheel. Which can be done but often isn't. Oftentimes balance wheels end up and times particularly discussing a bimetallic all bent up like the one in this discussion. If the balance wheel is out of round you definitely get a poise issue. You also get an issue if somebody pleases and out around balance wheel and then you fix the out of round now the wheel is poised incorrectly because somebody didn't physically make sure the balance wheel was correct in the first place. Yes people really do poise balance wheels that are neither flat or round it's quite annoying and then it typically with anything vintage there's an extreme likelihood of timing issues. Like the fun I had yesterday the wall thumb was 400 seconds fast and had a 202nd positional problem. So yes it's extremely common on vintage watches you're going to have things to fix from prior inappropriate repairs typically and it depends upon how it nitpicky you want to be here. In other words if you are statically poising the definition of poised would be if you give the balance wheel of push it will rotate eventually come to a stop and it will not rock back and forth at all is considered perfectly poised. Typically when I poise I don't worry about that I will let it rock back and forth because it still going to be within 15 seconds typically. Now the problem with statically poising absolutely perfectly is that it does not take into account the hairspring. This is why ideally if you are really obsessed you statically poise until your close and then finish with dynamic poising. This will take into account the hairspring collet that's probably not a poised collet. Yes Hamilton had another companies had poised collet's they hairspring itself affects the poise so for absolute perfect you have to dynamic poise. So the suggestion has been that it absolutely poised dynamically done balance wheel will not be statically poise absolutely perfectly.    this is an interesting one? In the United States of America over a time span and I don't remember the exact but it ended in the 60s there was a tear off on watches to protect the American watch industry. I've read the books on the tariffs specifications it would bump up the cost of better watches to making them expensive. This is why you will often see a nice Omega watch for instance that was regulated was adjusted and was still keeping really good time will be marked not adjusted. Because the quantity of jewels each jewel bumped up the cost adjustment adjustment and variety of positions bumped up the cost so a huge percentage of watches imported into this country will be not adjusted but they were adjusted at the factory it's just a terra thing then I suspect that even the cheapest of watches probably were somewhat adjusted because if they had zero adjustments I have no idea how bad the timekeeping would be? It's one of the problems of we don't actually have numbers of what the watches really should be doing we only have numbers of timekeeping basically when timing machines exist or for things like railroad grade watches where they absolutely had to know what the timekeeping is doing. So railroad timekeeping specification in this country is of watch Dependent up has to be within plus or -30/2 per week. Which if you compare it to the specifications of chronometer grade will ask which I think could be up to six seconds a day is better than a Rolex. this is one of my amusements at work. There we have that really nice which he timing machine full automatic microphone we look at every single watch and six positions and my boss once the watches all the keep really good time. So basically the watchmakers have learned to let the boss adjust the watches it seems to make him happy and we can do other things like service watches. So yesterday's fun on the 18 size Waltham to get the 400 timing down to think he got it down to 15 seconds it might've been better than that the Delta was still might've been within a minute much better than what it was before but still took more than an hour of time. When we don't specifically charge for this we charge for servicing of the watch we do not typically charge to make your watch keep time in multiple positions so yes it wastes a lot of time unless you're getting paid for it where it can definitely eat up a lot of time to fix vintage watches that I've had interesting repair histories. sorry I don't remember the brand name we once had a watch that was one of I take 1000 it actually was engraved number or something of something in other words it was a very expensive Swiss watch and I believe there was at least one shim under something. I always think of at the factory level if you have to place a shim to me it's a sign of poor manufacturing but there was a Swiss watch a nice watch that had it done. Of course what it may also be a sign of limited quantity of watches where things or adjusted at the factory we end up with interesting problems and I will pick on American pocket watches again with interesting repairs that can happen? For instance pocket watches dropped balance staff is broken possibly the whole jewels are broken and sometimes cap stones get broken. or worst-case I had a Hamilton 992 it actually had little notches taken out of the main plate I always wonder if it got hit by a train and things were dramatically bent in this watch somebody had ground the pallet fork bridge down to accommodate the balance wheel because the balance bridge had been bent to insane proportions it was bent so much it was no longer up and down in alignment so I always wondered if this particular watch got hit by a train. With its ultimate repair it would've been better to just replace the whole movement but instead we cannibalized another movements to replace all of the horribly mutilated parts. Now back to not watches hit by a train while somebody was crossing the railroad track. If the balance jewels are broken they are replaced but the same problem like we have on this group where do you get replacements? This means people in the field will get creative if they replace things with size differently than the original things will change. In other words the total length of the balance staff conceivably will change because they've changed the jewels and they're not properly sized. Then there's a problem of replacement balance staffs I personally have often theorized in the case of  bestfit  that they deliberately made the staffs oversize so the watchmaker can reduce the size. But what if you don't have a lay then what happens? A for instance the Hamilton 992B only has one balance staff as it's of friction staff but often times the friction staff doesn't fit because the replacement staff is slightly oversize which should be impossible but it happens. Often times I have to go through an assortment of staffs to find one that fits because I don't feel like reducing at the size to fit. More common though would be staffs with pivots that are too long and if the watchmaker does not have a lathe again how do they fix that problem well undesirable for us that have to deal with it down the road so an ideal perfect world the adjusted by the factory to whatever the specification was at the time and on a seven jewel American pocket watch it's not going to be railroad timekeeping. If we replace the staff in a proper fashion without bending or distorting anything the watch should keep time within the specification when it was originally made except of course we don't know what the specification was and they definitely did not have timing machines when this watch was made. If we replace the balanced staff with a factory original factory staff and everything should fit perfectly if the jewels were broken and we used factory jewels everything once again would be perfect. Although if you look in the parts book typically for American pocket watches for certain parts they recommend sending the entire watch or parts of the watch back because American watch manufacturing at least until the not sure exact date but sometime past the 20s definitely by the 50s watches were made in batches which is why everything has a serial number and the tools over the course of the batch tend to wear a little bit. So conceivably something made at the beginning and the end of the batch may not fit without adjustments. Plus of course there's variations in parts I like the pic on Elgin because they have one balance staff that comes in four different size variations and then a whole bunch of pivot variations all with the same part number so yes and an absolute perfect world which doesn't exist changing a balance staff with everything factory new would not require poising or truing the balance wheel because everything should still be perfect. But unfortunately in the 100+ year life of your watch things have happened. If you want to grasp that go back and start on page 1 of this discussion as the balance wheels in this discussion have had issues they're not flat the probably out of round there were issues with the jewels there is issues possibly with the staffs. Oh and yes apparently there's a donor watch and if the donor watch is not within a very close serial number range of the original watch it will have very likely sizing differences especially for anything related to the balance wheel because all the vintage watches were adjusted individually in the factory. If you look at a video on I can find it if you want to watch it on YouTube from I believe the 30s where you will see on escapement related stuff every single watch is adjusted which is why you can't just grab the balance wheel from one watch shove it into another one as they were adjusted at the factory                    
    • I see a lot of URLs pointing to 1drv.com which appears to be a CDN for OneDrive.
    • Hello and welcome from Leeds, England.  
×
×
  • Create New...