Jump to content

What Type Of Polishing Machine Do You Guys Use? A Dremel Or Bench Grinder Polishing Machine? And Why After I Polish, It Becomes Blurry?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Hi, i recently bought a dremel machine and dialux green color compound. But why after i polish, the surface becomes blurry? I was wondering is it because I'm using dremel? And is there anyway way to fix? Thanks a lot.

Edited by number98
Posted

I prefer to polish by hand, it keeps edges nice and sharp, but takes a lot longer.

Just curious, what metal are you polishing?

Posted

I prefer to polish by hand, it keeps edges nice and sharp, but takes a lot longer.

Just curious, what metal are you polishing?

Just normal 316 stainless steel. Oh. May i know what type of compound you use? 

Posted

A lot of the compounds leave a waxy film & normally require further hand polishing to remove the residue. On stainless steel I use a Dremel with hard felt mop & blue colour final finishing compound, finishing off with a pink colour Selvyt silver cloth. The hard felt mop used carefully will keep the edges sharp. On silver I just use the Selvyt silver cloth & on gold & gold plate I use a bugundy colour Selvyt gold cloth

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

your motor probably isn't the problem, green dialux is fantastic but keep in mind, like all compounds, it produces different results depending on what wheel you're applying it with, as well as how you're going about it.

in polishing steel I'll generally stick to chamois and fluffy cotton mops, the chamois is a little firmer, it will take out light to moderate surface damage (depending on how persistent you are and hot you run the piece.) and finish up steel to usually a cloudy mirror, sometimes a good mirror, but usually some way cloudy or imperfect.  

So I have to switch out to the softer cotton, which needs to be run a good deal faster than the chamois (make no mistake it firms up with speed, so fair warning, it will take off skin if you're careless) But it's softness means it can be used as a final finish with the same compound, taking out the cloudiness and imperfections of the previous stage of polishing. 

For greater damage i stock felt and grey dialux, but you have to be careful with this, especially if it's a mini mop like it is for me, and not a bench motor, it goes either way but especially when you can only work on a small area with a mini mop, a mop as hard as felt can very easily distort a piece, leaving dents and ridges that the light reflecting in it warps around and betrays your mistake. 

I advise you work backwards, learn how to get a really good final finish, and progressively learn to take out more and more damage without putting your own damage in and still being able to get that same final finish. It's better to lean on and potentially misuse compounds/mops/techniques that are too gentle than to lean on and potentially misuse things that are too harsh. 

Edited by Ishima
  • Like 2
Posted

your motor probably isn't the problem, green dialux is fantastic but keep in mind, like all compounds, it produces different results depending on what wheel you're applying it with, as well as how you're going about it.

in polishing steel I'll generally stick to chamois and fluffy cotton mops, the chamois is a little firmer, it will take out light to moderate surface damage (depending on how persistent you are and hot you run the piece.) and finish up steel to usually a cloudy mirror, sometimes a good mirror, but usually some way cloudy or imperfect.

So I have to switch out to the softer cotton, which needs to be run a good deal faster than the chamois (make no mistake it firms up with speed, so fair warning, it will take off skin if you're careless) But it's softness means it can be used as a final finish with the same compound, taking out the cloudiness and imperfections of the previous stage of polishing.

For greater damage i stock felt and grey dialux, but you have to be careful with this, especially if it's a mini mop like it is for me, and not a bench motor, it goes either way but especially when you can only work on a small area with a mini mop, a mop as hard as felt can very easily distort a piece, leaving dents and ridges that the light reflecting in it warps around and betrays your mistake.

I advise you work backwards, learn how to get a really good final finish, and progressively learn to take out more and more damage without putting your own damage in and still being able to get that same final finish. It's better to lean on and potentially misuse compounds/mops/techniques that are too gentle than to lean on and potentially misuse things that are too harsh.

Hello ishima, thank you for your reply. So after you've switched to a fluffy soft Cotten mop, do you put any compound or you don't? And normally how much compound do you "load" the wheel both the chamois leather and fluffy Cotten mop? I heard somewhere that loading the wheel with too much compound causes the surface to blur too right? I've been using the stock felt mop that came along with the dremel when I bought it. But whenever i polish, it caused the surface to turn blurry despite having literally all the scratches removed. Thanks.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted (edited)

Good questions, the rule of thumb for loading or charging wheels is 'little and often' so usually i stop charging almost as soon as i see the wheel start to turn a little green with the new compound and then after a few passes re charge the wheel, basically this is because polishing and buffing happens when both the compound, and the fibres of the wheel are able to contact the piece, charge a wheel too much and those fibres wont reach the piece, they'll be stuck behind a thick layer of compound.

I do charge my cotton wheel as well, but it's a good idea to have a a 'clean' cotton wheel as well in case you're running into problems in final finishing/cleaning, this is a wheel you don't charge but just use to remove used compound off of the surface of what you're polishing. This is because, sometimes trying to clean off residue can leave marks, usually I find it doesn't, i'll usually clean a piece of with with wet wipes or some spirit (isopropyl alcohol) and tissue/toothbrush and that's usually fine but strictly speaking it's not the way to do it, and on occasion it has left marks. If we were using a bench motor with a large cotton wheel you'd charge one side of it, and move the piece from the charged side to the uncharged side, doing the final polish and cleaning the piece of residue in one motion, but on mini mop that isn't practicable, hence keeping a spare, uncharged cotton mop. 

You'll probably need to get a lot of practice in, I found learning refinishing polishing to be immensely frustrating because the people who could do it didn't seem to know how to explain it or would leave key details out, so most of my learning was trial, error and me trying to work out the theory myself, I just hope I've helped you avoid that experience somewhat. 

There's this video that get's posted in every thread like this, because it's one of the best videos to explain refurbishing/refinishing, it covers a lot of the stuff I've mentioned, it's about polishing with a bench motor but a lot of it is transferable to hand held motors.


  Edited by Ishima
Posted

Good questions, the rule of thumb for loading or charging wheels is 'little and often' so usually i stop charging almost as soon as i see the wheel start to turn a little green with the new compound and then after a few passes re charge the wheel, basically this is because polishing and buffing happens when both the compound, and the fibres of the wheel are able to contact the piece, charge a wheel too much and those fibres wont reach the piece, they'll be stuck behind a thick layer of compound.

I do charge my cotton wheel as well, but it's a good idea to have a a 'clean' cotton wheel as well in case you're running into problems in final finishing/cleaning, this is a wheel you don't charge but just use to remove used compound off of the surface of what you're polishing. This is because, sometimes trying to clean off residue can leave marks, usually I find it doesn't, i'll usually clean a piece of with with wet wipes or some spirit (isopropyl alcohol) and tissue/toothbrush and that's usually fine but strictly speaking it's not the way to do it, and on occasion it has left marks. If we were using a bench motor with a large cotton wheel you'd charge one side of it, and move the piece from the charged side to the uncharged side, doing the final polish and cleaning the piece of residue in one motion, but on mini mop that isn't practicable, hence keeping a spare, uncharged cotton mop.

You'll probably need to get a lot of practice in, I found learning refinishing polishing to be immensely frustrating because the people who could do it didn't seem to know how to explain it or would leave key details out, so most of my learning was trial, error and me trying to work out the theory myself, I just hope I've helped you avoid that experience somewhat.

There's this video that get's posted in every thread like this, because it's one of the best videos to explain refurbishing/refinishing, it covers a lot of the stuff I've mentioned, it's about polishing with a bench motor but a lot of it is transferable to hand held motors.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YMuWrI-sCj8

Hello ishima thank you for your reply! I just bought two chamois leather mop mounted and two fluffy cotton mop mounted from cousinsuk! Yeah. The video you've attached is one of the best video regarding about polishing I've ever seen. I didn't know buffing could remove such a deep dent/scratches. I thought it was not possible. As I normally used sandpaper to sand the dent/deep scratches! Really thank you so much for taking the time to answer my question :)

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

Good questions, the rule of thumb for loading or charging wheels is 'little and often' so usually i stop charging almost as soon as i see the wheel start to turn a little green with the new compound and then after a few passes re charge the wheel, basically this is because polishing and buffing happens when both the compound, and the fibres of the wheel are able to contact the piece, charge a wheel too much and those fibres wont reach the piece, they'll be stuck behind a thick layer of compound.

I do charge my cotton wheel as well, but it's a good idea to have a a 'clean' cotton wheel as well in case you're running into problems in final finishing/cleaning, this is a wheel you don't charge but just use to remove used compound off of the surface of what you're polishing. This is because, sometimes trying to clean off residue can leave marks, usually I find it doesn't, i'll usually clean a piece of with with wet wipes or some spirit (isopropyl alcohol) and tissue/toothbrush and that's usually fine but strictly speaking it's not the way to do it, and on occasion it has left marks. If we were using a bench motor with a large cotton wheel you'd charge one side of it, and move the piece from the charged side to the uncharged side, doing the final polish and cleaning the piece of residue in one motion, but on mini mop that isn't practicable, hence keeping a spare, uncharged cotton mop.

You'll probably need to get a lot of practice in, I found learning refinishing polishing to be immensely frustrating because the people who could do it didn't seem to know how to explain it or would leave key details out, so most of my learning was trial, error and me trying to work out the theory myself, I just hope I've helped you avoid that experience somewhat.

There's this video that get's posted in every thread like this, because it's one of the best videos to explain refurbishing/refinishing, it covers a lot of the stuff I've mentioned, it's about polishing with a bench motor but a lot of it is transferable to hand held motors.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YMuWrI-sCj8

Hello ishima thank you for your reply! I just bought two chamois leather mop mounted and two fluffy cotton mop mounted from cousinsuk! Yeah. The video you've attached is one of the best video regarding about polishing I've ever seen. I didn't know buffing could remove such a deep dent/scratches. I thought it was not possible. As I normally used sandpaper to sand the dent/deep scratches! Really thank you so much for taking the time to answer my question :)

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Posted

If you are getting blurry/foggy end result after any compound it means it is ready for a wash. Always thoroughly clean parts after each buff or polish in a degreaser ( fairly liquid will suffice if you have no chrono clean or related cleaners ). The compounds are binded using oils so the film they leave needs to be removed. It really is crucial to clean between each stage, the best results come from patience and knowing your compounds. Just to note there is a big difference between polishing and buffing, they are not one and the same and require different techniques. I could write a book on it but i have nee the time :)

 

Im much like Geo, i prefer hand polishing using traditional techniques with various oils, woods, burnishers, and fine powders, the results are far superior ( Geo knows what i mean ;) )

  • Like 1
Posted

6c8a41ced33d3b910bb65561829e5f67.jpg

Firstly, I use the white compound on the cotton wheel to polish off scratches. There will be swirls left on the surface at this stage.

3a6bb51000d192bd65dfc78a9a0fad47.jpg

Then, I use the little felt wheel applied with some 5.0 micron diamond paste to polish off the swirls. But the surface is still a little blurry at this stage.

Now I'll applied some 3.0 micron diamond paste on a new felt bob and buff the surface to near mirror finished.

fac222323f26d34d0b1b69a030015381.jpg

Final buffing by hand using Cape Cod metal polish to get the sparkling mirror finished. I can see my reflection [emoji2] grinning ear to ear, and sometimes my wife's too as I always showed her the end results.

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Tool for removing or pressing the bezel? Most likely you have to remove the bezel (with a knife) before removing old crystal or inserting a new one. You can press the bezel with the crystal press if you have a suitable die with straight walls or otherwise a die that has enough clearance that it doesn't touch the crystal when pressing the bezel.
    • This will be my first crystal replacement, I have a press, but looking at the watch I wonder if I might need a bezel tool also. Any and all help appreciated. 
    • I'm not entirely sure you fully understand what he's doing in the video. For one thing he's giving examples of things like about 16 minutes he talks about opening up the regulator just a little bit. Opening up the regulator slows the watch down to compensate for that he moves the regulator fast and now it's keeping time again but the regulator pins are too far apart. I have an image down below on top of it shows the effect of regulator pins and amplitude. If the regulator pins are farther apart than the example down below then at a higher amplitude timekeeping will be much worse. Why the regulator pins are supposed to be adjusted as an average rule approximately twice the thickness of the mainspring itself. In other words if you look at the spacing it have one half of the hairspring thickness on either side of the hairspring itself. There is like he talks about the video a little bit of adjustment here and there. So in his example where he opened them up it will really dramatically screw up timekeeping based on amplitude. Then when you get to the 20 some minutes like you say he is adjusting the regulator pins closer together to get a more even timekeeping based on amplitude and amplitude changes are caused by going to various positions. Then and the other example of the image down below regulator pins too far apart and they hairspring is not centered and look what that does the timekeeping. So hairspring is supposed to be centered regulator pins are supposed to properly spaced. Then you get reasonably even timekeeping like it shows in the upper image. It's not like we're regulating out positional errors like poising errors because that's something entirely different.   In the part number above and in the video both of you left off details. I which version of either of your watches I will just make you's timing specifications for your watch down below may specify how you're supposed to do it other words you wind up the watch fully wound up you wait 10 to 60 minutes in the four positions it should be within 60 seconds. Yes it can be closer but you may not actually get zero.     Now let's compare with the 2892 and see where we might have a discrepancy. First off we have a problem of which one is a using did he use the chronometer grade 1 or the top grade or what?  None is basically just much tighter timing tolerances. So when he's using an example watch conceivably might be a chronometer grade watch then things are going to be much more  perfect than what you're going to see.       NH35_TG.pdf ETA 2892-A2 Manufacturing info.pdf
    • Note the 8992 is 850 pounds for a liter. I think this is really for industrial settings like they say, where it would be used as a final bath in a 20,000 buck cleaning machine. I use the 8981.   That is excellent- I don't often get to see a serviced watch 5 years later, but when I do I expect to see pretty much the same oiling on the balance jewels as when it went out. I think at that area, being essentially sealed, it really should remain fairly pristine for likely 10 years. It's why some makers go to the trouble to use cap jewels on the escape wheel as well- not so much for friction reduction, but to keep the oil longer where it really counts.
×
×
  • Create New...