Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

This is the most appalling result I have ever come across from a so called professional watch repairer.

A friend asked if I could possible help out a friend of his who handed his Omega Seamaster in for repair and service because of moisture inside the case. He left it he watch feeling confident that he would have his pride and joy back working perfectly. Well a few weeks past and there was no message to say the watch was ready, or that any problems had been encountered. Weeks then became months then a year, a very patient man had had enough and went to the shop and asked for his watch back.

This is what he was given:-

post-124-0-31438600-1442691735_thumb.jpg

post-124-0-04226200-1442691826_thumb.jpg

I said I would have a look and reassemble the watch for him, after all there had only been a bit of moisture in it and the parts didn't have any severe corrosion on them. When I placed all the parts on a sheet of paper, there seemed to be a lot more than there should be. On close inspection, I found all sorts of issues that attributed to the increase in parts none if which could be attributed to slight moisture.

Centre Second Fourth Wheel - The gear wheel was off the shaft.

Escape Wheel - The wheel was off the shaft.

Auto Reversing Wheel - In bits.

Rotor Bearing - In bits.

Intermediate Ratchet Wheel - Separated.

Intermediate Date Wheel - Separated.

Lume on minute hand damaged

Lume on dial stained with oil.

post-124-0-87226400-1442691962_thumb.jpg

I managed save the date wheel by re-staking the gears and will sort out the lume, the rest have been ordered from Cousins. I'll let you know how it goes when I get the parts.

  • Like 2
Posted

The funny thing is Andy, because of the value, I would have told him to take it to a professional!

  • Like 1
Posted

This is the most appalling result I have ever come across from a so called professional watch repairer.

A friend asked if I could possible help out a friend of his who handed his Omega Seamaster in for repair and service because of moisture inside the case. He left it he watch feeling confident that he would have his pride and joy back working perfectly. Well a few weeks past and there was no message to say the watch was ready, or that any problems had been encountered. Weeks then became months then a year, a very patient man had had enough and went to the shop and asked for his watch back.

This is what he was given:-

attachicon.gifimage.jpg

attachicon.gifimage.jpg

I said I would have a look and reassemble the watch for him, after all there had only been a bit of moisture in it and the parts didn't have any severe corrosion on them. When I placed all the parts on a sheet of paper, there seemed to be a lot more than there should be. On close inspection, I found all sorts of issues that attributed to the increase in parts none if which could be attributed to slight moisture.

Centre Second Fourth Wheel - The gear wheel was off the shaft.

Escape Wheel - The wheel was off the shaft.

Auto Reversing Wheel - In bits.

Rotor Bearing - In bits.

Intermediate Ratchet Wheel - Separated.

Intermediate Date Wheel - Separated.

Lume on minute hand damaged

Lume on dial stained with oil.

attachicon.gifimage.jpg

I managed save the date wheel by re-staking the gears and will sort out the lume, the rest have been ordered from Cousins. I'll let you know how it goes when I get the parts.

Have ID'ed all of the bits now.

Posted

Have ID'ed all of the bits now.

Hi CB & Will.

I fully assembled the movement less the broken parts to work out exactly what was required. So I now know where everything goes including all the screws. I have it in bits again, and today will clean all the parts to allow assembly as soon as the new bits arrive. Watch this space!

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh dear... This guy should not even be allowed to change batteries in cheap quartz movements !!

Wheel off the shaft, really ??? You really, really, really have to try hard to get that kind of result....

 

Great job Geo, hope it all works out in the end.

Posted

Looking forward to see the end product Geo. I'm sure it will be better than new when you are done with it! Maybe  this is a good excuse for a tutorial?

 

Cheers,

 

Bob

Posted

Seems hard to believe but, look at some of the pictures of Watchmakers tear downs on the web....

I thought the worst part on my 1120 was the date ring spring area, just under the top right of your picture. Didn't like installing that as it also retains a wheel. Good luck.

Cheers, Chris

Sent from my XT1039 using Tapatalk

Posted

The Omega owner is fortunate to have you do the work . Good luck with it and I'm looking forward to the finished product . Take as many pics as you can so guys like me can learn from your experience .

I got that same Omega not too long ago , I love it . I just ordered 2 more Omegas ,... a vintage Seamaster and a vintage Constellation . The seamaster meeds a New crystal , but I'll sort that stuff out when the watches arrive .

Posted

Well I started assembly yesterday and have discovered some more issues. Once assembled the movement did start to run..........very badly! On close inspection, I discovered that the parts that I didn't replace were exceptionally slack in their jewels. That means I will have to replace every pivot in the watch. So today I ordered a barrel arbour, intermediate wheel and pallet fork. The only pivots that were OK were the on the balance shaft.

Initially I was at a loss to understand how so many wheels were off their arbours, I think I now have the answer. I'm 99% certain that the parts have been soaked in rust remover, and this has eaten away the steel making the pivots rough and smaller in diameter and causing the wheels to fall off.

I'll keep you posted regarding how things go.

Posted

Well I started assembly yesterday and have discovered some more issues. Once assembled the movement did start to run..........very badly! On close inspection, I discovered that the parts that I didn't replace were exceptionally slack in their jewels. That means I will have to replace every pinion in the watch. So today I ordered a barrel arbour, intermediate wheel and pallet fork. The only pinions that were OK were the on the balance shaft.

Initially I was at a loss to understand how so many wheels were off their arbours, I think I now have the answer. I'm 99% certain that the parts have been soaked in rust remover, and this has eaten away the steel making the pinions rough and smaller in diameter and causing the wheels to fall off.

I'll keep you posted regarding how things go.

It,s never easy Geo but good analysis  work.  The costs must be mounting towards the national debt. :startle:

Posted

They sure are CB! :(

Especially as Omega spares prices have rocketed in light of the impending ceasing to supply , ordered some parts on Tuesday couldn't believe how the prices have at least doubled :-(

Posted

That looks like a lot of work but the end result will hopefully be worth the effort. I would have thought that the shop would have at least bothered to put the thing back together before handing it back unless the customer just said "I want it right now!" and that is why they got it back in pieces?

 

Either way, I hope that you post some pics when it is back up and running again.

Posted

I've just finished replacing everything that has a pinion except the balance wheel and the results are looking pretty good!

post-124-0-53374800-1444568408_thumb.jpe

I'll post a set of pictures of the assembly when I finish the watch.

  • Like 4
Posted

I've just finished replacing everything that has a pinion except the balance wheel and the results are looking pretty good!

attachicon.gifimage.jpeg

I'll post a set of pictures of the assembly when I finish the watch.

Well done Geo treat yourself to a nice drink

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I sure appreciate your comment! I will look into one of those or maybe something similar. I of course will check your video to have a better idea.  by the way, that’s a beautiful lathe! Mine is a little peersless, but I just bought a Boley & Leinen that is on its way. That’s the one I am looking a motor for. It comes with a motor, but I want to replace it for  one that has a speed controller.
    • Indeed. I would not attempt one. Here is my messy Sherline setup
    • This conversation is becoming a very confusing. The etachron system is a very nice system for manufacturing watches. As you know it consists of two components the stud and the regulator pins. Beautiful thing of this system is you can open up your regulator pins center the hairspring and as you close the pins they will close equally on both sides providing you centered it in the first place. It's not like you're going to become closer to one side or the other as the definition of the regulator pins is a bit confusing it's not exactly a slot sort of. I'm thinking maybe a little eight reading will be helpful for you. Then the file name was changed by me at the US patent but the wording of Seiko may or may not actually be attached to it soared up? I just did that so I can find it in my files. Normally patents are in people's name if they work for a company the company name will be there you'll notice the person lives in Japan which is interesting as the name would imply that this is a Swiss product. Somewhere I think I have the patents for the stud and I believe that is Swiss like a lot of things their Japanese and Swiss and then the Japanese let the Swiss name stand as it seems you more popular in case as you read up on the patents of the regulator pins or pin will see and it should explain exactly how and why it works also why it's important to always close at an open in specific directions because the pins actually have a shaped to them it's very hard to see the shape as it's very tiny.   As a reminder with this system it's mass-produced. I wouldn't be at all surprised if they use cameras and computers to do all of the adjustments.  The meaning of this is that the majority of watches will function as there supposed to and do what they're supposed to do the system will allow us for some minor in tolerance and has more than likely as I said no human hand is ever touched those watches that's the way they left the factory and they work fine. US2007091729A1 seiko etachron.pdf
    • These still seem stupid expensive for a bottle, but still £100 cheaper than than the Moebius ones. Anyone have any experience of these: https://www.cousinsuk.com/product/epilame-fixodrop-special-bottle-horotec
    • Yes, this is not a basic part. Here are some pictures of making one  
×
×
  • Create New...