Jump to content

Spares / Repair watches - My habit of always repairing...

ColinC
 Share

Recommended Posts

ColinC WRT Addict

ColinC

Posted
Posted

Where do you stop?

Last week I dug around in my large collection of spares / repair watches to find myself a quick challenge and selected a CAMY Club Star which had a FHF 96-4 movement.  I had paid about £10 for it.

It wasn't running and after opening it up I found a few things that were not quite right...
1. The balance cock had different finishing than the rest of the movement (clearly a replacement)
2. It is missing the dial screws and the dial is held on with Rodico
3. Other CAMY watches I have seen have CAMY signed on the movement this one didn't
4 The balance spring looked out of shape
5. The setting lever spring was beginning to crack - I find this is a typical failure in this movement.
6. On the dial and on the train wheel bridge it says 17 Jewels but I can only find 15 Jewels


What I failed to notice as I took it apart was that it was missing the calendar driving wheel.

After cleaning all the parts I went about trying to get the balance to swing again properly - this was a real pain!  The hairspring was glued to the stud and the stud was friction fit to the regulator.  There was a screw to hold the stud in place but loosening / removing that made no difference.  

After many hours I had the watch ticking again and I was impressed with my work -  290º of amplitude! and not too much variation in rate and beat error in all positions

It is at this point I start to work on the dial side and notice that I am missing the calendar driving wheel...

I look at my list of watches with FHF 96-4 movements that I haven't worked on yet and choose a watch that is missing its crown and stem and where the gold plated case is badly worn and the dial is scratched (a suitable donor I thought....). I had paid about £5 for it
Inside that watch is a much nicer FHF 96-4 movement with all 17 Jewels, a balance that looks good and that can actually run before I clean it.  Of course the setting lever spring is broken!

So now what do I do now?
Do I buy a calendar driving wheel and 2 setting lever springs and some dial screws and get both watches working?
Do I put the nicer movement inside the watch with the nicer case and dial?  To be honest the CAMY dial and case are not in great shape either!

I know the concept of "sunk cost" but I spent so long getting that crappy balance to swing again I feel it would be a shame not to use it

Here are some before pics....
image.thumb.png.db69ffd8e55543dcc5639d77bf9e0773.pngimage.thumb.png.00e8fe3bb99dc34fffe3aca4a25dea63.png

rehajm Super WRT Addict

rehajm

Posted
Posted (edited)

If you’re a hobbyist don’t focus on sunk costs. If you’re not a hobbyist…don’t focus on sunk costs 😂…

…sorry, a bit of economist humor if there is such a thing but really it all depends how much you’d like to see the watch in good order.

 

Edited by rehajm
  • Like 3
Jon Super WRT Addict

Jon

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, ColinC said:

Where do you stop?

Such a deep question. Is there any stopping, once started? These and other existential questions are only for you to know.

I think you know what you are going to do, as you have put so much time and effort into breathing life into these watch movements

I think it's about the achievement rather than the money, as long as that isn't silly money

  • Like 3
ColinC WRT Addict

ColinC

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I have ordered a new calendar driving wheel and a few setting lever springs.  I guess I will keep the watches as original as I found then rather than trying to make 1 good watch and 1 lesser watch since that will leave me with 2 non original watches...

 

Geotex WRT Addict

Geotex

Posted
Posted (edited)

As I transitioned from being a small-time watch collector to someone who spends a fair amount of time on watch repair, I stopped worrying about "original" and am just happy with "functional" most of the time on watches like these. 🙂

Edited by Geotex
  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • transporter
      Smiths rim wind and set

      By transporter · Posted

      Ok, as per pictures I have a smiths rim set and wind on the bench, swimming in oil but all sorted. The fault I have is the mainspring bridle has lost its tab/notch/hook, like a hebdomas pocket watch the mainspring is fitted to a bridal in the barrel which slides around on full wind onto 4 notches in the barrel wall, thus stopping damage to the mainspring by over enthusiastic winding. So my questiion is this, what is the best way to create another hook in the bridal, my thoughts are along the same lines as making a new hole in the mainspring end, annealing etc, but what and how to make the hook?? I have a pair of barrel hook pliers that work great in soft brass but won’t even scratch the bridal, what I don’t want to do is whack a hole into it and not have a hook. the pictures are of the bridal ( broken) and a hebdomas ( complete ) incase you are wondering what I’m on about. And a few of the serivce. Thanks for any advise.
    • zx6rfool
      Replacing, upgrading Ronda 715 Harley?

      By zx6rfool · Posted

      Decided to give the case and bracelet a good cleaning and my first shot at polishing/brushing. Went with the Cape Cod polishing cloth and gray scotch brite method.  Before First; Then After; Then comparing to some original links from when the watch was new to now.       
    • praezis
      Unitas 6376

      By praezis · Posted

      What is this (left of the red line)? hairspring? Frank
    • nickelsilver
      Unitas 6376

      By nickelsilver · Posted

      It's either bent or hung up on something or both. The hexane won't hurt it, and hanging from a balance tack indefinitely won't hurt it.   If the spring is glued to the stud there's a chance that the glue was softened and the outer coil stuck to the stud. Haven't seen that happen, but I suppose it could. Don't know if hexane affects the glue used either.
    • tonydagee
      Unitas 6376

      By tonydagee · Posted

      Hello all. some help required here from the community please. I serviced this movement, which was running reasonably well, but the balance spring which was running healthily before I started, after cleaning in hexane for 30 secs, is all bunched up at the stud. I did store the balalance on a tack thereafter for a day.   could the spring be strained under gravity? I demagnetised of course, and the balance is squeaky clean. some help would be much appreciated. Thanks, Tony G    
×
×
  • Create New...