Jump to content

Horotec Two Stage Crystal Press Problems

SSTEEL

By SSTEEL
in Tools & Equipment

 Share

Recommended Posts

SSTEEL Distinguished Member

SSTEEL

Posted
Posted

Don't know if I am alone in this, but I have experienced issues with the Horotec two stage crystal press, the first time using it, the shaft that has a secondary finer thread snapped off, so contacted cousins, and they sent me a replacement shaft saying its the first they have experienced this.

 

Now the replacement has broken now too, several months later.  I'm not using the press incorrectly, its just that the secondary finer threaded shaft gets stuck, and I have to use a pair of pliers to undo it so it will retract, but the latest time, the darn thing snapped off just like the first.

 

I will be contacting Horotec directly regarding this, as surely this is a manufacturer problem with the quality of parts.

 

Just wondering if any of you guys have experienced the same?

 

This is the product..

 

11946768405_418e3c59e8_b.jpg

 

Screw Closing Press (Two Stage), Horotec - Cousins UK

 

And this is the end result..

 

25625778640_f751932751_k.jpghorotec two stage press broken by Micky Aldridge, on Flickr

jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted

I have an Indian copy of this press, without the finer feature. Unrelated to the problem exposed I would not recommend it because to its design it flexes easily. There are similar ones on which the pillars are lined up with the screw, which is much better.

Alaskamick WRT Addict

Alaskamick

Posted
Posted (edited)

Not sure how this tool operates. Why are you unscrewing the bottom part in the first place.

 

You also refer to a crystal press but surely this is a caseback press?

Edited by Alaskamick
bobm12 Distinguished Member

bobm12

Posted
Posted

Hi Alaskamick,

 

Micky is having issues with the bottom part of the press that should move contrary to the effect of the main shaft which in turn screws down to exert the pressure. The effect of both the main shaft and the bottom part with their opposite movement makes the press to appear to exert a steady, downward force without friction on the pressed item. The part that is breaking is binding, i.e. not turning when it should. It should be definitely a manufacturer's thing. I would try and alleviate the problem by putting some grease there but it should not happen.

 

This press can be used for both, case and/or crystal and comes with double duty dies. I have a Witschi equivalent which uses the same dies but I haven't had any issues with that one. The price was about the same (when I bought it) now it is almost double.

 

wit19000-08.jpg

Some other presses are sold as "dedicated" for crystals only (which I think is more like a marketing thing rather than their true application...a press is a press anyway!) an example would be the Bergeon 5500 which used to be listed as either crystal press only or back & crystal press depending on the site. Maybe the distinction is made in dependence of how "level" or precise they are when exerting pressure...then the cheapo ones can not be crystal presses I suppose.

 

Cheers,

 

Bob

 

PS. Sorry Micky, I don't have that press model so I can't really say anything of help in your case! I hope the issues are resolved to your satisfaction...without further expenses. Cheers!

  • Like 1
  • 2 weeks later...
SSTEEL Distinguished Member

SSTEEL

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Got a reply from Horotec :)

Dear Sir,

 
I noted your problem with our MSA 07.150 (two-stages press). 
 
We know this problem and found a solution with a new two-stages shaft.
 
I will send you this part in a few days and I hope you will not have any problem with this Horotec tool.
 
Best regards
 
  • Like 2
Mark Distinguished Member

Mark

Posted
Posted
Got a reply from Horotec [emoji4]

Dear Sir,

  I noted your problem with our MSA 07.150 (two-stages press).    We know this problem and found a solution with a new two-stages shaft.   I will send you this part in a few days and I hope you will not have any problem with this Horotec tool.   Best regards  

That's a great result Mickey. It's nice to know that Horotec cares for their customers.

Thanks for sharing.

bobm12 Distinguished Member

bobm12

Posted
Posted

Very nice and well done both you and Horotec, Micky! I'm glad it ended well...and I might consider getting more Horotec stuff in the future to add to my already numerous Horotec items!

Cheers,

Bob

presto0906 Watch Enthusiast

presto0906

Posted
Posted
On 3/19/2016 at 10:55 AM, jdm said:

I have an Indian copy of this press, without the finer feature. Unrelated to the problem exposed I would not recommend it because to its design it flexes easily. There are similar ones on which the pillars are lined up with the screw, which is much better.

Got one of these too. It flexes as supplied because the bore of the pillars is too much in excess of the bolt diameters. Just unscrew the thing, wrap a single layer of insulation tape around the un-threaded portion of the bolts - and reassemble. You will find its now rock-solid - sorted :)

jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, presto0906 said:

Got one of these too. It flexes as supplied because the bore of the pillars is too much in excess of the bolt diameters. Just unscrew the thing, wrap a single layer of insulation tape around the un-threaded portion of the bolts - and reassemble. You will find its now rock-solid - sorted :)

Good that tape worked for you.. In my opinion it simply can't be used for glasses, and in fact isn't sold for that. I have since then got a real heavy one. 

presto0906 Watch Enthusiast

presto0906

Posted
Posted
8 minutes ago, jdm said:

Good that tape worked for you.. In my opinion it simply can't be used for glasses, and in fact isn't sold for that. I have since then got a real heavy one. 

Totally agree - I bought it solely to re-fit 'snap-on' case backs - and after the tape mod it does this perfectly OK. They are often advertised as also being a crystal press but in my view the item is not robust enough for that purpose.   

SSTEEL Distinguished Member

SSTEEL

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

And its here.

Ive tested it, and the second stage part now springs back up when pressure released.  Its certainly an improved component now, theres no longer a allen key bold on the underside of the die holder.

26304177275_a270b72a57_k.jpgDSC09738.JPG by Micky Aldridge, on Flickr

Edited by SSTEEL
  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • transporter
      Smiths rim wind and set

      By transporter · Posted

      Hi watchweasol, yes that is a way of doing it I suppose, I have a pair of mainspring hole making pliers on their way off eBay, the ones with the different shaped punches. I may be able to use them to make a hook.
    • pablocchristo
      Introduction

      By pablocchristo · Posted

      Hello everyone, Glad to be here. 
    • ColdWind
      EMG Crown DL63

      By ColdWind · Posted

      This is a modern watch, the crown is definitely made from solid 316l steel. You must have heated the crown to some 200C caused the surface colour to change to light yellow. It's similiar to steel tempering. Yes it is the chromium oxide that forms during the heating that gives rise to the colours you see as you know stainless steel contains chromium. The fact the crown is SS lead me to a question, you've never heard of the alum method? Because alum would work perfectly in this case, instead of drilling, which, there is always a risk of damaging the crown, I would just let the crown chilling in some warm alum solution for 1-2 days and the job is done.   Sure can but the thing is the crown is not just mirror finishing, the lock symbol is polish while its background is some sand-blasted finishing so it would be hard to replicate that. You can buff it all shiny but losing the sand-blasted finishing means it won't look exactly like before.   Gasket is always tricky to me. I would try to use some gasket that look closest to the broken one in term of thickness and diameter, and check if the replacement gasket fit with some friction to the case tube. Lastly you can still use alum at this point.
    • Mark
      Ad Free WRT

      By Mark · Posted

      No mate. Sorry if that offends you! Also please don’t take threads off-topic. I thank you sir. 
    • RichardHarris123
      Introduction

      By RichardHarris123 · Posted

      Hello and welcome from Leeds, England. 
×
×
  • Create New...